Acquittal of Accused in Cheque Bounce Case on the basis of Friendly Loan

Hon'ble Delhi High Court in a recent Judgment acquitted an accused in Cheque Bounce Case based on plea of friendly loan mainly on the ground that  the complainant could not show the details as to from whom the loan money was arranged and thus, it was difficult to believe in the solvency of the complainant in advancing loan.



 



 



IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI 



 



CRL.L.P.424/2017 Date of Decision: 28.07.2017 



 



MUNESH KUMARI                  ….. PETITIONER



 



versus 



 



IMRAN & ANR                 …. RESPONDENTS 



 



CORAM:-




HON’BLE MR JUSTICE ASHUTOSH KUMAR 



 



ASHUTOSH KUMAR, J (ORAL) 



 



Crl.L.P.424/2017



 



1. The petitioner/complainant claims to have advanced a loan of Rs.2 lakh to the respondent on 12.01.2014 for a period of one year as the respondent was in need of money for running his business of sale of mobile sets and repairs. 



 



2. According to the petitioner/complainant, the loan was advanced after arranging the same from various other sources. The details of those sources have neither been stated in the complaint nor could be ascertained at the time of trial. 



 



3. The petitioner/complainant, in his complaint as well as in his evidence by way of affidavit had affirmed the fact that the respondent, on request, handed over the cheque in question for repayment of loan amount on 27.05.2015 in the morning. This assertion was ratified by CW2 during trial. 



 



4. The case of the petitioner is that in discharge of the loan liability, the respondent drew a cheque bearing No.000020 dated 27.05.2015 for an amount of Rs.2 lakhs drawn on HDFC Bank, Mayur Vihar, Phase-I, Delhi in favour of the petitioner. The said cheque was dishonoured for “insufficiency of funds”. A demand notice dated 08.07.2015 was sent to the respondent. Since money was not paid to the petitioner, a complaint was filed. 



 



5. The Trial Court was of the view that in the absence of the details as to from whom the loan money was arranged by the petitioner, it was difficult to believe in the solvency of the petitioner in advancing loan. The Trial Court was also of the view that there was nothing on record even to infer about the earnings and the financial strength of the petitioner for him to have advanced a loan of Rs.2 lakhs for business purposes. 



 



6. No written agreement or receipt appears to have been placed on record to prove that the loan was actually advanced. The evidence adduced on behalf of the petitioner regarding advance of loan is only photocopy of a Voter ID Card of the respondent (Ex. CW1/1) on which it was written in Hindi that loan of Rs.2 lakhs was taken along with the signature of the respondent. This, the Trial Court held, was no evidence in support of the fact that loan was obtained from the petitioner/complainant. There is no mention in the aforesaid document (Ex. CW1/1) about the name of the lender and no date of the loan has been given. 



 



7. The respondent, during trial sought to rebut the presumption further by bringing in evidence that on the day when the cheque is said to have been handed over by the respondent to the petitioner i.e. on 27.05.2015 in the morning, the respondent was at Dubai. Ex. DW1/1 is copy of the flight tickets of the respondent. Copy of the passport bearing the immigration stamp showing the departure of the respondent from India on 17.04.2015 and his arrival in India on 06.07.2015 was pressed by the respondent to demonstrate that the case of the petitioner/complainant was false. 



 



8. The Trial Court, therefore, following the decision rendered in K. Prakashan vs. P.K. Sundaran: 2007 (4) CCC 713 (SC) andVipul Kumar Gupta vs. Vipin Gupta: 20012 (4) JCC (NI) 248 held that in the absence of any evidence to show the solvency of the petitioner for him to advance loan to the respondent, the complaint must necessarily fail. 



 



9. The Supreme Court in Vijay vs. Laxman 2013: (V) AD (SC) 243 has held that in the absence of any documentary or other evidence to show that any such loan transaction had indeed taken place between the parties, is a significant circumstance to be taken into account. 



 



10. The presumption of the cheque in question having been issued in discharge of the debt has been successfully rebutted by the respondent.




11. Section 139 of Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 is in the nature of a reverse onus clause. The accused/respondent is only required to raise a probable defence which creates doubt about the legally enforceable debt or liability. The standard of proof for doing so would be on the basis of “preponderance of probabilities” and not “beyond the shadow of any doubt”. 



 



12. This court finds no merit in the present leave petition as the judgment delivered by the Trial Court cannot be faulted with. 



 



13. Leave declined. 



 



14. This criminal leave petition is dismissed. 



JULY 28, 2017 



 

Enquiry in update?

Social Pages



GET IN TOUCH WITH US

PANKAJ KUMAR & CO.

CHAMBER NO.1104 ROHINI COURT ROHINI

advpk1@gmail.com

8800543454

http://advocate-delhi.com

 

  DIVORCE LAWYER IN ROHINIDIVORCE LAWYER IN TIS HAZARI COURTDIVORCE ADVOCATE IN ROHINI COURTDIVORCE ADVOCATE IN PITAMPURADIVORCE LAWYER IN PITAMPURADIVORCE LAWYER IN PASCHIM VIHARDIVORCE ADVOCATE IN PASCHIM VIHARBEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN ROHINIBEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN DELHIBEST DIVORCE LAWYERS IN DELHIBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATES IN DELHIBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARI COURTBEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN TIS HAZARI COURTBEST CIVIL LAWYER IN ROHINI COURTBEST CRIMINAL LAWYER IN ROHINI COURTBEST CRIMINAL ADVOCATE IN ROHINI COURTBEST CIVIL LAWYER IN TIS HAZARI COURTMUTUAL CONSENT LAWYER IN ROHINI COURTMUTUAL CONSENT LAWYER IN TIS HAZARI COURTMUTUAL CONSENT ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARI COURTMUTUAL CONSENT ADVOCATE IN ROHINI COURTDIVORCE LAWYER IN SECTOR 5 ROHINIDIVORCE LAWYER IN SECTOR 3 ROHINIDIVORCE LAWYER IN MODEL TOWNDIVORCE LAWYER IN ASHOK VIHARDIVORCE LAWYER IN SECTOR 9 ROHINIDIVORCE LAWYER IN ALIPURDIVORCE LAWYER IN NARELABEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN ROHINI COURTBEST DIVORCE LAWYERMUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE LAWYERARBITRATION LAWYERCHEQUE BOUNCE CASE LAWYERMONEY RECOVERY SUIT LAWYER/ADVOCATEDIVORCE ADVOCATE IN ROHINIDIVORCE ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARIBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATEBEST CIVIL ADVOCATEBEST CRIMINAL ADVOCATEBEST PROPERTY LAWYER/ADVOCATEBEST PROPERTY LAWYER IN ROHINIBEST PROPERTY LAWYER IN DELHIBEST CIVIL LAWYER IN DELHIBEST HIGH COURT LAWYER IN DELHIBEST HIGH COURT ADVOCATE IN DELHIBEST CRIMINAL APPEAL LAWYER IN DELHIBEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN PASCHIM VIHARBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN PASCHIM VIHARCOURT MARRIAGE LAWYER IN ROHINICOURT MARRIAGE ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARICOURT MARRIAGE ADVOCATE IN PRASHANT VIHARCOURT MARRIAGE ADVOCATE IN ROHINI COURTCOURT MARRIAGE ADVOCATE IN MODEL TOWNCOURT MARRIAGE ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARIDOMESTIC VIOLENCE ADVOCATE IN ROHINIDOMESTIC VIOLENCE LAWYER IN TIS HAZARIDOMESTIC VIOLENCE ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARIBEST DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ADVOCATE/LAWYERBEST MAINTENANCE CASE LAWYER IN ROHINI COURTBEST CHILD CUSTODY CASE LAWYER IN ROHINI COURTBEST CHILD CUSTODY CASE ADVOCATE IN ROHINI COURTBEST CHILD CUSTODY CASE ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARIBEST CHILD CUSTODY CASE LAWYER IN PITAMPURABEST CHILD CASE CUSTODY LAWYER IN PRASHANT VIHARBEST 498A LAYWER IN ROHINIBEST 498A ADVOCATE IN ROHINI COURTBEST 498A LAYWER IN TIS HAZARIBEST 498A ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARI COURTMUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE LAWYER IN ROHINIMUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE LAWYER IN TIS HAZARIMUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE LAWYER IN PITAMPURAMUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE LAWYER IN DELHIDIVORCE LAWYERDIVORCE LAWYER IN NEW DELHIDIVORCE LAWYER DELHIDELHI HIGH COURT LAYWERDELHI HIGH COURT LAWYER FOR DIVORCE CASEPARTITION CASE LAWYERDELHI HIGH COURT LAWYERBEST CIVIL LAWYERMONEY RECOVERY SUIT LAWYER IN ROHINIMONEY RECOVERY SUIT LAWYER IN TIS HAZARIMONEY RECOVERY SUIT ADVOCATE IN ROHINIMONEY RECOVERY SUIT ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARICHEQUE BOUNCE CASE LAWYER IN ROHINI COURTCHEQUE BOUNCE CASE LAWYER IN TIS HAZARICHEQUE BOUNCE CASE ADVOCATE IN ROHINICHEQUE BOUNCE CASE ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARICORPORATE LAWYER IN ROHINICORPORATE LAWYER IN DELHICORPORATE LAWYER IN NEW DELHIBUSINESS LAWYER IN ROHINIBUSINESS LAWYER IN DELHIMATRIMONIAL DISPUTE LAWYER IN ROHINIMATRIMONIAL DISPUTE LAWYER IN TIS HAZARIMATRIMONIAL DISPUTE ADVOCATEEVICTION SUIT LAWYER IN ROHINI DELHICOURT MARRIAGE LAWYER IN ROHINI DELHIBEST LAWYER IN ROHINI DELHIBEST CRIMINAL LAWYER IN ROHINI DELHIBEST CRIMINAL ADVOCATE IN ROHINI DELHIBEST CRIMINAL ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARI DELHIBEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN SAKETBEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN DWARKADIVORCE LAWYER IN SAKETDIVORCE ADVOCATE IN SAKETBEST FAMILY COURT LAWYERBEST FAMILY COURT ADVOCATE IN ROHINIAFFORDABLE DIVORCE LAWYER IN DELHIAFFORDABLE LAWYER IN DELHI HIGH COURTAPPEAL LAWYER IN DELHI HIGH COURTCIVIL SUIT LAWYER IN DELHI HIGH COURTNRI DIVORCE LAWYER IN DELHIDOWRY CASE LAWYER IN DELHIDOWRY CASE LAWYER IN ROHINIDIVORCE LAWYERS IN DELHIDIVORCE ADVOCATES IN DELHIDIVORCE BEST LAWYER IN DELHIDIVORCE BEST ADVOCATE IN DELHIDIVORCE BEST LAWYER IN NEW DELHIDIVORCE BEST ADVOCATES IN NEW DELHIDIVORCE BEST ADVOCATE IN SOUTH DELHIDIVORCE LAWYER IN SOUTH DELHIDIVORCE LAWYER IN NORTH DELHIDIVORCE LAWYER IN WEST DELHIDIVORCE LAWYER IN TIS HAZARIEXPERT DIVORCE LAWYEREXPERT DIVORCE LAWYERSBEST LAWYERSBEST ADVOCATESBEST ADVOCATES IN DELHIBEST LAWYERS IN DELHIBEST LAWYER IN DELHIBEST FAMILY CASE LAWYER IN DELHIBEST FAMILY COURT LAWYER IN DELHIBEST FAMILY COURT LAWYER IN ROHINIBEST COURT MARRIAGE LAWYER IN ROHINIBEST COURT MARRIAGE LAWYER IN DELHIBEST COURT MARRIAGE ADVOCATE IN ROHINIBEST COURT MARRIAGE ADVOCATE IN ROHINI COURTBEST DOMESTIC VIOLENCE LAWYER IN ROHINI COURTBEST DOMESTIC VIOLENCE LAWYER IN TIS HAZARI COURTBEST MUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE LAWYER IN DELHIBEST MUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN DELHIBEST MUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN ROHINIBEST MUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE LAWYER IN ROHINIBEST MUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE LAWYER IN TIS HAZARIBEST MUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARIBEST FAMILY LAW LAWYER IN DELHIBEST FAMILY LAWYER IN DELHIFEES OF MUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE IN DELHIFEES OF MUTUAL DIVORCE IN DELHIPROCEDURE OF MUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE IN DELHIPROCEDURE OF MUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE IN INDIAEXPERT DIVORCE ADVICE IN DELHIEXPERT DIVORCE CASE ADVICE IN NEW DELHIEXPERT DIVORCE OPINION IN NEW DELHICHILD SUPPORT LAWYER IN DELHICHILD SUPPORT LAWYER IN ROHINICHILD SUPPORT LAWYER IN TIS HAZARIBEST LAWYER IN ROHINIBEST LAWYER IN TIS HAZARIBEST ADVOCATE IN PASCHIM VIHAREXPERT DIVORCE CASE LAWYERBEST DIVORCE CASE LAWYERBEST DIVORCE CASE LAWYER IN DELHIBEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN NEW DELHIBEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN DELHI NCRBEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN NCTBEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN INDIABEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN NEW DELHIBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN DELHI NCRBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARIBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN INDIADIVORCE ADVOCATE IN DELHICHEQUE BOUNCE ADVOCATE IN DELHICHEQUE BOUNCE CASE ADVOCATE IN DELHICHEQUE BOUNCE CASE ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARI COURTCHEQUE DISHONOUR LAWYER IN TIS HAZARI COURTCHEQUE DISHONOUR LAWYER IN ROHINI COURTCHEQUE DISHONOUR ADVOCATE IN ROHINI COURTCHEQUE DISHONOUR LAWYER IN ROHINICHEQUE DISHONOUR LAWYER IN SAKET COURTCHEQUE DISHONOUR LAWYER IN KARKARDOOMACHEQUE BOUNCE LAWYER IN TIS HAZARICHEQUE BOUNCE CASE LAWYER IN DELHIARBITRATION LAWYER IN DELHIARBITRATION CASE LAWYER IN DELHICORPORATE LAWYER IN ROHINI DELHICORPORATE LAWYER IN TIS HAZARI DELHICORPORATE LAWYER IN DELHI INDIAPROPERTY CASE LAWYER IN DELHI INDIAPROPERTY CASE ADVOCATE IN DELHI INDIADIVORCE LAWYER IN DELHI INDIABEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN DELHI INDIABEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN DELHI INDIABEST DOMESTIC VIOLENCE CASE LAWYER IN DELHI INDIABEST CHILD CUSTODY CASE LAWYER IN DELHI INDIABEST ALIMONY LAWYER IN DELHI INDIABEST BUSINESS DISPUTE LAWYER IN DELHI INDIAEXPERT BUSINESS DISPUTE LAWYER IN DELHI INDIAEXPERT LAWYER IN DELHI INDIAEXPERT BUSINESS ADVOCATE IN DELHI INDIABEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN NEW DELHI INDIABEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN ROHINI DELHIBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN ROHINI DELHIBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN TIS HAZARI DELHIBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN SAKETBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN DWARKA DELHIBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN KARKARDOOMA COURT DELHIBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN PATIALA HOUSE COURT DELHIBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN NORTH DELHIBEST DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN SOUTH DELHIBEST MUTUAL CONSENT DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN NEW DELHIAFFORDABLE DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN DELHIAFFORDABLE DIVORCE ADVOCATE IN ROHINI DELHIAFFORDABLE DIVORCE LAWYER IN ROHINI DELHIAFFORDABLE DIVORCE LAWYER IN TIS HAZARI COURTSERVICE MATTER LAWYER IN DELHIWRIT MATTER LAWYER IN DELHI HIGH COURTWRIT MATTER LAWYER IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIADIVORCE LAWYER IN DELHI HIGH COURTCIVIL LAWYER IN DELHI HIGH COURTCRIMINAL LAWYER IN DELHI HIGH COURTDIVORCE ADVOCATE IN DELHI HIGH COURTCORPORATE LAWYER IN DELHI HIGH COURTCOMPANY LAWYER IN DELHI HIGH COURTADVOCATE FOR DRT IN DELHIADVOCATE FOR NCLT IN DELHIFAMILY MATTER LAWYER IN DELHIBEST FAMILY CASE LAWYER IN NEW DELHIBEST FAMILY CASE LAWYER IN ROHINI DELHIBEST FAMILY CASE LAWYER IN TIS HAZARI DELHIBEST FAMILY COURT LAWYER IN ROHINI DELHILAW FIRM IN DELHILAW FIRM IN NEW DELHIBEST LAW FIRM IN NEW DELHIBEST LAW FIRM IN ROHINI DELHIBEST LAW FIRM IN ROHINI COURTBEST LAW FIRM IN DELHI HIGH COURTBEST LAW FIRM IN TIS HAZARIBEST DIVORCE LAW FIRM IN DELHIBEST DIVORCE LAW FIRM IN NEW DELHIBEST DIVORCE LAW FIRM IN SOUTH DELHIBEST CORPORATE LAW FIRM IN DELHIDivorce Law Firm in IndiaProperty Lawyer in DelhiLawyer for NRIProperty lawyer for NRIBest Property Lawyer for Foreign ClientBest NRI LawyerBest Divorce Lawyer for NRIBest Divorce Lawyer for ForeignerBest Mutual Consent Divorce Lawyer In DelhiBest Law Firm in DelhiBest Property Law Firm in DelhiBest Divorce Lawyer in DelhiBest Divorce Lawyer in IndiaAffordable Lawyer for Mutual Divorce in DelhiAffordable Lawyer for Divorce in DelhiAffordable Divorce Lawyer in Tis HazariAffordable Divorce Lawyer in Rohini DelhiExpert Divorce Lawyer in Rohini DelhiExpert Divorce Law Firm in DelhiBest Cheque Bounce Lawyer in DelhiBest Cheque Bounce Law Firm in DelhiBest Business Dispute Law Firm in DelhiBest Commercial Dispute Law Firm in DelhiDivorce Lawyers In DelhiMutual Consent Divorce Lawyer in North DelhiChild Custody Lawyers in SaketDivorce Lawyer in Model Town498A Lawyer in West DelhiDomestic Violence Lawyer in RohiniChild Maintenance Lawyer in PitampuraAnnulment of Marriage Lawyer in RohiniCivil Case Lawyer in PitampuraProperty Case Lawyer in Paschim ViharMutual Consent Divorce Lawyer in Paschim ViharDivorce Lawyer in KarkardoomaMutual Divorce Lawyer in DelhiSpecialist Divorce Lawyer in DelhiExpert Child Custody Lawyer in Delhisee more


powered by Advertroindia